Respectfully, I built my first lasers in the mid-seventies in high school, back in the olden days. A dye laser (rhodamine, IIRC, from Scientific American plans), nitrogen gas laser, and a He-Ne gas laser for which I destroyed literally hundreds of pounds of glass tubing while learning to make apparati. As I recall, that one never did work right! But I do appreciate all the nuances, Ivo. One needn't know all the ins-and-outs of lasers in order to make an informed purchase. For the vast majority of what is currently marketed and legal in the US as pointer-style lasers, duty cycle is indeed a reasonably accurate predictor of intensity at a given output rating- yes you are right that there are reasons for operating the module at less than 100% duty cycle- -BUT- it certainly appears to be the primary reason why some "5mw" lasers are significantly brighter than other "5mw" lasers, all other things being equal. I plan to purchase a true 5mw, 100% duty-cycle unit, and will gladly make it available for side-by-side comparisons. Want to design the experiment, Ivo?
From: Ivo Stutznegger <ics_ute@yahoo.com>
I would definitely agree with the first statement of your first post on this thread. -ÂI've discovered that powerrating is not in itself a foolproof indicator of brightness.Â
However an indication that the laser operates at less than 100% duty cycle doesnÂt necessarily mean that it is dimmer. There is a very good reason to operate a portable battery powered laser at less than 100% duty cycle.
__________________________________ Yahoo! Music Unlimited Access over 1 million songs. Try it free. http://music.yahoo.com/unlimited/
Quoting Chuck Hards <chuckhards@yahoo.com>:
I plan to purchase a true 5mw, 100% duty-cycle unit, and will gladly make it available for side-by-side comparisons.
Want to design the experiment, Ivo?
I'm all in favor of getting Patrick to circle above SPOC while we take turns at him. The first laser or bullet to bring him down wins! ;) Just kidding Patrick!
diveboss@xmission.com wrote:
I'm all in favor of getting Patrick to circle above SPOC while we take turns at him. The first laser or bullet to bring him down wins! ;) Just kidding Patrick!
Actually, a couple of SPOC star parties ago I circled SPOC a few times waiting for someone to try out their laser. No luck... Keep em flyin! Patrick
participants (3)
-
Chuck Hards -
diveboss@xmission.com -
Patrick Wiggins