Re: [math-fun] There must be something wrong with Mathematica's Round function--
MBGreen>The question still seems likely to confuse 4th graders. "How to use rounding to estimate ..."? What would the kids say if we gave them almost the exact same problem immediately afterwards, but added 2 days to both the United State and Italy numbers. I'm sure they'd expect the estimate of the **difference** to remain the same... Right. Next time I see him, I'll do this to the poor kid: In[9]:= Round[45, 10] - Round[35, 10] Out[9]= 0 In[11]:= Round[35, 10] - Round[34, 10] Out[11]= 10 Also, where do they say 10 anywhere? Why not In[18]:= Round[42, 100] - Round[13, 100] Out[18]= 0 ? --rwg On 2013-12-05 17:49, Bill Gosper wrote: Oops, logophagy time. Docfiend NeilB points out: In[5]:= Round[42, 10] - Round[13, 10] Out[5]= 30 is almost certainly the question's intent. --rwg On Tue, Dec 3, 2013 at 11:12 PM, Bill Gosper <billgosper@gmail.com><billgosper@gmail.com>wrote: It has no effect on this 4th Grade homework problem: "Estimate: Workers in Italy receive an average of 42 vacation days per year. Workers in the United States receive an average of 13 vacation days per year. Explain how to use rounding to estimate how many more vacation days workers in Italy receive each year." --rwg Another nice one: "Write 47,000 in expanded form." I suggested forty-seven Ms. This is a private school. Everybody says parTISSiple.
Now you've uncovered an actual Mathematica bug. If Round handles 5's consistently, Out[9] should be 10, not 0. -- Gene
________________________________ From: Bill Gosper <billgosper@gmail.com> To: math-fun@mailman.xmission.com Sent: Friday, December 6, 2013 2:10 AM Subject: Re: [math-fun] There must be something wrong with Mathematica's Round function--
MBGreen>The question still seems likely to confuse 4th graders. "How to use rounding to estimate ..."? What would the kids say if we gave them almost the exact same problem immediately afterwards, but added 2 days to both the United State and Italy numbers. I'm sure they'd expect the estimate of the **difference** to remain the same...
Right. Next time I see him, I'll do this to the poor kid: In[9]:= Round[45, 10] - Round[35, 10]
Out[9]= 0
In[11]:= Round[35, 10] - Round[34, 10]
Out[11]= 10
Also, where do they say 10 anywhere? Why not
In[18]:= Round[42, 100] - Round[13, 100]
Out[18]= 0 ? --rwg
On 2013-12-05 17:49, Bill Gosper wrote:
Oops, logophagy time. Docfiend NeilB points out: In[5]:= Round[42, 10] - Round[13, 10]
Out[5]= 30
is almost certainly the question's intent. --rwg
On Tue, Dec 3, 2013 at 11:12 PM, Bill Gosper <billgosper@gmail.com><billgosper@gmail.com>wrote:
It has no effect on this 4th Grade homework problem: "Estimate: Workers in Italy receive an average of 42 vacation days per year. Workers in the United States receive an average of 13 vacation days per year. Explain how to use rounding to estimate how many more vacation days workers in Italy receive each year." --rwg Another nice one: "Write 47,000 in expanded form." I suggested forty-seven Ms. This is a private school. Everybody says parTISSiple. _______________________________________________ math-fun mailing list math-fun@mailman.xmission.com http://mailman.xmission.com/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/math-fun
participants (2)
-
Bill Gosper -
Eugene Salamin