[math-fun] car talk puzzler
Last week's car talk puzzler http://www.cartalk.com/content/puzzlers has an interesting pseudo-probabilty twist. The puzzle (3/14/15, President's Day): My friend, Max says to me, "I just read that three of the first five presidents of the United States died, ready for this? On the Fourth of July. What do you think the odds of that happening are?" I reply, "No idea. But, I'll give you 10-to-one odds that I can name at least one of the three." Now I don't know anything about the first five presidents, he writes, except that their names are: Washington, Adams, Jefferson, Madison and Monroe. In that order. Others might enjoy looking at this, so I won't give my analysis now. Enjoy, Scott
On 24/03/2015 19:10, Scott Huddleston wrote:
Last week's car talk puzzler http://www.cartalk.com/content/puzzlers has an interesting pseudo-probabilty twist. The puzzle (3/14/15, President's Day):
My friend, Max says to me, "I just read that three of the first five presidents of the United States died, ready for this? On the Fourth of July. What do you think the odds of that happening are?" I reply, "No idea. But, I'll give you 10-to-one odds that I can name at least one of the three."
Now I don't know anything about the first five presidents, he writes, except that their names are: Washington, Adams, Jefferson, Madison and Monroe. In that order.
(The actual puzzle is: given that "I" don't know anything more than that, how can "I" be so confident of identifying one of the three presidents correctly?) There is an exactly isomorphic puzzle in Martin Gardner's book "Puzzles from other worlds", collected from a column he ran in Isaac Asimov's Science Fiction Magazine. -- g
I wrote:
There is an exactly isomorphic puzzle in Martin Gardner's book "Puzzles from other worlds", collected from a column he ran in Isaac Asimov's Science Fiction Magazine.
Er, except that the exact way the question is asked there is different and if you read Gardner's version of the puzzle it may give away a key part of the answer to the Car Talk one. So if you have that book but no recollection of the puzzle and want to solve it afresh, best do it before comparing. -- g
That's easy - Monroe Brent On 3/24/2015 12:10 PM, Scott Huddleston wrote:
Last week's car talk puzzler http://www.cartalk.com/content/puzzlers has an interesting pseudo-probabilty twist. The puzzle (3/14/15, President's Day):
My friend, Max says to me, "I just read that three of the first five presidents of the United States died, ready for this? On the Fourth of July. What do you think the odds of that happening are?" I reply, "No idea. But, I'll give you 10-to-one odds that I can name at least one of the three."
Now I don't know anything about the first five presidents, he writes, except that their names are: Washington, Adams, Jefferson, Madison and Monroe. In that order.
Others might enjoy looking at this, so I won't give my analysis now.
Enjoy,
Scott
_______________________________________________ math-fun mailing list math-fun@mailman.xmission.com https://mailman.xmission.com/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/math-fun
participants (3)
-
Gareth McCaughan -
meekerdb -
Scott Huddleston