Re: [math-fun] math-fun Digest, Vol 153, Issue 4
From: Dan Asimov <asimov@msri.org> To: math-fun <math-fun@mailman.xmission.com> Subject: [math-fun] Random variable puzzle Message-ID: <3C0B9325-43FC-4DDA-A42E-69EC9AF69FFF@msri.org> Content-Type: text/plain; charset=utf-8
Suppose X, Y, Z, W are real random variables with a joint distribution such that each one has a finite mean and standard deviation.
Suppose that all pairs of these random variables have the same correlation coefficient:*
R = rho(X,Y) = rho(X,Z) = rho(X,W) = rho(Y,Z) = rho(Y,W) = rho(Z,W) .
Find the minimum possible value of R.
For the following 4x4 Hadamard matrix (entries +1 and -1) -+++ +-++ ++-+ +++- each row has mean=1/2, variance=1, and all rows are orthogonal. If we instead take these four rows of an 8x8 Hadamard +-+-+-+- ++--++-- +--++--+ ++++---- then each row has mean=0, variance=1, and all rows orthogonal.
But I don't see a proof that 0 is the minimum possible value of R. —Dan
On Nov 4, 2015, at 11:28 AM, Warren D Smith <warren.wds@gmail.com> wrote:
I wrote:
Suppose X, Y, Z, W are real random variables with a joint distribution such that each one has a finite mean and standard deviation.
Suppose that all pairs of these random variables have the same correlation coefficient:*
R = rho(X,Y) = rho(X,Z) = rho(X,W) = rho(Y,Z) = rho(Y,W) = rho(Z,W) .
Find the minimum possible value of R.
For the following 4x4 Hadamard matrix (entries +1 and -1) -+++ +-++ ++-+ +++- each row has mean=1/2, variance=1, and all rows are orthogonal.
If we instead take these four rows of an 8x8 Hadamard +-+-+-+- ++--++-- +--++--+ ++++---- then each row has mean=0, variance=1, and all rows orthogonal.
participants (2)
-
Dan Asimov -
Warren D Smith