[math-fun] Mathematical Enchantments
A couple of days from now, I'll be launching a monthly blog called "Mathematical Enchantments". I'm hoping I'll get support from some folks in my mathematical-social network who can look at preliminary versions of my posts and make suggestions for how to improve them (or at least keep me from embarrassing myself too badly). Anyone who makes helpful comments on the preliminary version of one of my essays will be acknowledged at the end of the posted version. Do you have any general advice for me on the verge of this large undertaking? e.g., things you've especially liked (or disliked) in the work of math-popularizers in the past? One thing I urgently need is people willing to write spiffy demos (JavaScript would be best). Only a few of you do this, but maybe others of you know how to find people who do this sort of thing well? I'm hoping that fame (not fortune) will be an adequate enticement, especially for the compulsive coders among you. I will always welcome suggestions for topics, though for the first year years of the blog I'm all set. Fear No Spam: I don't plan to write to you again unless you reply (except perhaps if I'm posting on a topic that you have special knowledge about). I'd love to have lots of readers of preliminary versions, but if you just want to follow what I publish, go to http://mathenchant.org from time to time (starting this coming Wednesday evening). I may also create a podcast version; tips on starting a podcast series are also welcome. I've decided to put my blog on wordpress.com, at least for now; if any of you have wordpress experience, as relates to inclusion of mathematical equations and diagrams and animations, I'd appreciate your advice. Here's the zeroeth installment, which I hope to post on June 17. [picture of pseudosphere] At some moment in the past five years I realized that math, in addition to being the way I earn my living, is something even more important for my happiness: it's a consolation for living in a world without magic. By "magic" I don't mean make-believe magic, the sort you'll see in a stage-show; I mean _real_ magic -- the kind that you read about in books when you were a child, and hoped to encounter someday, but gradually stopped believing in as, year after year, the world you inhabit failed to deliver any evidence that magic existed. And by "math" I don't mean the inflexible cookbook math that too often is the only kind children learn; I mean the game that research mathematicians get to play, where they break those cookbook rules, adding new spices to old recipes and inventing entirely new ones. Lots of people (most notably Martin Gardner and more recently Arthur Benjamin, Persi Diaconis, Ron Graham, and Colm Mulahy) have talked and written about the links between math and magic tricks, but hardly anyone talks about the way that math, for many people who do research in it, satisfies a craving for the fantastic that most of us haven't outgrown (even if we've persuaded ourselves that we have). Indeed, I think that most children get glimpses, all too easily forgotten, of math as a wondrous ticket to other worlds. My goal in Mathematical Enchantments is to reawaken in my readers this childlike relationship to the subject, and to make this view of math enticing and even natural. And if you are an actual child, or an actual mathematician, and your sense of mathematical wonder is already awake and active, all the better! There'll be lots of new games you can play. These things are fun, and fun is good. I'll do my best not to assume that you have much mastery of math beyond number-sense and basic algebra. But I'll make heavy demands on your imagination, and your willingness to bend and stretch your mind into new shapes, or even to try to split your mind into two parts (more on this soon!). And I'll assume that you're curious about new ways of looking at familiar things, and bold enough to dance with new ideas that initially seem quite crazy, temporarily letting go of old ideas that get in the way of the dance (the letting go is usually harder than the dancing). Do you want to see a geometry in which there's a single point at infinity? Or another geometry that has infinitely many of them? Do you want to see a number system in which infinity is equal to its own negative? And another number system in which plus infinity and minus infinity are two different numbers? Are you intrigued by the prospect of a logic in which "It is false that P is false" is subtly different from the proposition "P is true"? Do you want to see a way of thinking about turn-taking games in which it makes sense to say you're ahead by exactly half a move? Or a geometry in which you have to make two full turns to be back in the orientation you started in? Or a geometry in which you change size, Alice-like, as you move through space? Do you want to learn how to count the elements of infinitely large sets, and learn why some of them, in a certain sense, have a negative number of elements? Then you'll probably enjoy this blog. I may occasionally touch on some ways in which math is relevant to our day-to-day world, such as the shape of snowflakes (why do the symmetrical ones all have six arms, never eight?), or beer cans (why did Budweiser redesign their can?), or traffic jams (what simple step could all of us take to make traffic jams evaporate more quickly?), or converting between miles and kilometers (how can memorizing the first few Fibonacci numbers help you do these conversions in your head?) --- or the way that some of the mind-bending possibilities I mentioned in the last paragraph are actually covertly at work in our world. But really, my true passion is not the ways mathematics helps us in this world, but the ways mathematics takes us out of it, expanding our imaginations beyond the pull of gravity and even the shackles of space and time. If you want to know why math is useful, read the recent books of Jordan Ellenberg and Steven Strogatz, and the many fine books by authors who preceded them. But if you ever get tired of living in just one world, and our world in particular, and secretly pine for a passport to other, weirder realms, I hope to be your monthly tour-planner. In this blog you'll meet some kids' games that are as fun (and challenging) for grownups as they are for children, a forgotten fractal from the nineteenth century, a simple model of sand piles that will probably perplex researchers for decades to come, high-dimensional spaces and the things that live there, and dozens of other fruits of the mathematical enterprise. And if you've ever wondered what the deal is with .999… (with infinitely many 9's after the decimal point, whatever that means!), well, I've got a whole bunch of ways to look at that one to offer you. I'll also tackle some deeper issues, such as, what is the nature of this wondrous mathematical realm? If it's "out there", why can't we see it? Or, if the facts of mathematics are all in our heads, why are they so obdurately unaffected by our wishes? And why do so many mathematical heads contain the same mathematical facts, if these facts are just figments? What do mathematicians mean by "proof", and why do they care so much about it? How does the human mind engage in mathematics? How should mathematics be taught? How do researchers in pure mathematics decide what projects to spend their time on, and when they are engaged in those projects, what the heck are they actually DOING? One model for what I'm trying to accomplish is the writings of Martin Gardner. Some other models are … well, actually, I'm not going tell you; I'd much rather imitate these writers and see if anyone notices what I'm up to. That's a game I'll be playing with you over the next few years. In the meantime, I'll mention that not all of my role-models wrote about mathematics or even about science. I'll close with a poem by Clarence Wylie whose final line compresses into ten syllables a surprisingly large chunk of what I'll be trying to convey in these many dozens of blog posts: PARADOX Not truth, nor certainty. These I forswore In my novitiate, as young men called To holy orders must abjure the world. “If …, then …,” this only I assert; And my successes are but pretty chains Linking twin doubts, for it is vain to ask If what I postulate be justified Or what I prove possess the stamp of fact. Yet bridges stand, and men no longer crawl In two dimensions. And such triumphs stem In no small measure from the power this game, Played with the thrice attenuated shades Of things, has over their originals. How frail the wand, but how profound the spell! Jim Propp
I'd be happy to read and contribute some JS. On Mon, Jun 15, 2015 at 9:08 AM, James Propp <jamespropp@gmail.com> wrote:
A couple of days from now, I'll be launching a monthly blog called "Mathematical Enchantments". I'm hoping I'll get support from some folks in my mathematical-social network who can look at preliminary versions of my posts and make suggestions for how to improve them (or at least keep me from embarrassing myself too badly). Anyone who makes helpful comments on the preliminary version of one of my essays will be acknowledged at the end of the posted version.
Do you have any general advice for me on the verge of this large undertaking? e.g., things you've especially liked (or disliked) in the work of math-popularizers in the past?
One thing I urgently need is people willing to write spiffy demos (JavaScript would be best). Only a few of you do this, but maybe others of you know how to find people who do this sort of thing well? I'm hoping that fame (not fortune) will be an adequate enticement, especially for the compulsive coders among you. I will always welcome suggestions for topics, though for the first year years of the blog I'm all set.
Fear No Spam: I don't plan to write to you again unless you reply (except perhaps if I'm posting on a topic that you have special knowledge about). I'd love to have lots of readers of preliminary versions, but if you just want to follow what I publish, go to http://mathenchant.org from time to time (starting this coming Wednesday evening). I may also create a podcast version; tips on starting a podcast series are also welcome.
I've decided to put my blog on wordpress.com, at least for now; if any of you have wordpress experience, as relates to inclusion of mathematical equations and diagrams and animations, I'd appreciate your advice.
Here's the zeroeth installment, which I hope to post on June 17.
[picture of pseudosphere]
At some moment in the past five years I realized that math, in addition to being the way I earn my living, is something even more important for my happiness: it's a consolation for living in a world without magic.
By "magic" I don't mean make-believe magic, the sort you'll see in a stage-show; I mean _real_ magic -- the kind that you read about in books when you were a child, and hoped to encounter someday, but gradually stopped believing in as, year after year, the world you inhabit failed to deliver any evidence that magic existed.
And by "math" I don't mean the inflexible cookbook math that too often is the only kind children learn; I mean the game that research mathematicians get to play, where they break those cookbook rules, adding new spices to old recipes and inventing entirely new ones.
Lots of people (most notably Martin Gardner and more recently Arthur Benjamin, Persi Diaconis, Ron Graham, and Colm Mulahy) have talked and written about the links between math and magic tricks, but hardly anyone talks about the way that math, for many people who do research in it, satisfies a craving for the fantastic that most of us haven't outgrown (even if we've persuaded ourselves that we have). Indeed, I think that most children get glimpses, all too easily forgotten, of math as a wondrous ticket to other worlds.
My goal in Mathematical Enchantments is to reawaken in my readers this childlike relationship to the subject, and to make this view of math enticing and even natural. And if you are an actual child, or an actual mathematician, and your sense of mathematical wonder is already awake and active, all the better! There'll be lots of new games you can play. These things are fun, and fun is good.
I'll do my best not to assume that you have much mastery of math beyond number-sense and basic algebra. But I'll make heavy demands on your imagination, and your willingness to bend and stretch your mind into new shapes, or even to try to split your mind into two parts (more on this soon!). And I'll assume that you're curious about new ways of looking at familiar things, and bold enough to dance with new ideas that initially seem quite crazy, temporarily letting go of old ideas that get in the way of the dance (the letting go is usually harder than the dancing).
Do you want to see a geometry in which there's a single point at infinity? Or another geometry that has infinitely many of them? Do you want to see a number system in which infinity is equal to its own negative? And another number system in which plus infinity and minus infinity are two different numbers? Are you intrigued by the prospect of a logic in which "It is false that P is false" is subtly different from the proposition "P is true"? Do you want to see a way of thinking about turn-taking games in which it makes sense to say you're ahead by exactly half a move? Or a geometry in which you have to make two full turns to be back in the orientation you started in? Or a geometry in which you change size, Alice-like, as you move through space? Do you want to learn how to count the elements of infinitely large sets, and learn why some of them, in a certain sense, have a negative number of elements? Then you'll probably enjoy this blog.
I may occasionally touch on some ways in which math is relevant to our day-to-day world, such as the shape of snowflakes (why do the symmetrical ones all have six arms, never eight?), or beer cans (why did Budweiser redesign their can?), or traffic jams (what simple step could all of us take to make traffic jams evaporate more quickly?), or converting between miles and kilometers (how can memorizing the first few Fibonacci numbers help you do these conversions in your head?) --- or the way that some of the mind-bending possibilities I mentioned in the last paragraph are actually covertly at work in our world.
But really, my true passion is not the ways mathematics helps us in this world, but the ways mathematics takes us out of it, expanding our imaginations beyond the pull of gravity and even the shackles of space and time. If you want to know why math is useful, read the recent books of Jordan Ellenberg and Steven Strogatz, and the many fine books by authors who preceded them. But if you ever get tired of living in just one world, and our world in particular, and secretly pine for a passport to other, weirder realms, I hope to be your monthly tour-planner.
In this blog you'll meet some kids' games that are as fun (and challenging) for grownups as they are for children, a forgotten fractal from the nineteenth century, a simple model of sand piles that will probably perplex researchers for decades to come, high-dimensional spaces and the things that live there, and dozens of other fruits of the mathematical enterprise. And if you've ever wondered what the deal is with .999… (with infinitely many 9's after the decimal point, whatever that means!), well, I've got a whole bunch of ways to look at that one to offer you.
I'll also tackle some deeper issues, such as, what is the nature of this wondrous mathematical realm? If it's "out there", why can't we see it? Or, if the facts of mathematics are all in our heads, why are they so obdurately unaffected by our wishes? And why do so many mathematical heads contain the same mathematical facts, if these facts are just figments? What do mathematicians mean by "proof", and why do they care so much about it? How does the human mind engage in mathematics? How should mathematics be taught? How do researchers in pure mathematics decide what projects to spend their time on, and when they are engaged in those projects, what the heck are they actually DOING?
One model for what I'm trying to accomplish is the writings of Martin Gardner. Some other models are … well, actually, I'm not going tell you; I'd much rather imitate these writers and see if anyone notices what I'm up to. That's a game I'll be playing with you over the next few years. In the meantime, I'll mention that not all of my role-models wrote about mathematics or even about science.
I'll close with a poem by Clarence Wylie whose final line compresses into ten syllables a surprisingly large chunk of what I'll be trying to convey in these many dozens of blog posts:
PARADOX
Not truth, nor certainty. These I forswore In my novitiate, as young men called To holy orders must abjure the world. “If …, then …,” this only I assert; And my successes are but pretty chains Linking twin doubts, for it is vain to ask If what I postulate be justified Or what I prove possess the stamp of fact. Yet bridges stand, and men no longer crawl In two dimensions. And such triumphs stem In no small measure from the power this game, Played with the thrice attenuated shades Of things, has over their originals. How frail the wand, but how profound the spell!
Jim Propp _______________________________________________ math-fun mailing list math-fun@mailman.xmission.com https://mailman.xmission.com/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/math-fun
-- Mike Stay - metaweta@gmail.com http://www.cs.auckland.ac.nz/~mike http://reperiendi.wordpress.com
On 6/15/2015 9:08 AM, James Propp wrote:
... Fear No Spam: ... go to http://mathenchant.org ... from time to ...
it may not be you, but playing the video in divx has *lots* of adds and playing the the windows player gets strange behaviour. thanks -- Honesty is a very expensive gift. So, don't expect it from cheap people - Warren Buffett http://tayek.com/
Is anyone else seeing ads when they try to view my "Magic, Magic, and Mystery" video? Does anyone know why this would happen, and in particular, whether it has something to do with Wordpress? The video is hosted at http://faculty.uml.edu/jpropp/MathMagicMystery.mp4, so I'm sure that the ads Ray is seeing have nothing to do with the hosting site. Jim Propp On Mon, Jun 15, 2015 at 2:32 PM, Ray Tayek <rtayek@ca.rr.com> wrote:
On 6/15/2015 9:08 AM, James Propp wrote:
... Fear No Spam: ... go to http://mathenchant.org ... from time to ...
it may not be you, but playing the video in divx has *lots* of adds and playing the the windows player gets strange behaviour.
thanks
-- Honesty is a very expensive gift. So, don't expect it from cheap people - Warren Buffett http://tayek.com/
_______________________________________________ math-fun mailing list math-fun@mailman.xmission.com https://mailman.xmission.com/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/math-fun
I don't see any ads on your video. I suspect that Ray's computer may have malware. On Mon, Jun 15, 2015 at 11:44 AM, James Propp <jamespropp@gmail.com> wrote:
Is anyone else seeing ads when they try to view my "Magic, Magic, and Mystery" video?
Does anyone know why this would happen, and in particular, whether it has something to do with Wordpress?
The video is hosted at http://faculty.uml.edu/jpropp/MathMagicMystery.mp4, so I'm sure that the ads Ray is seeing have nothing to do with the hosting site.
Jim Propp
On Mon, Jun 15, 2015 at 2:32 PM, Ray Tayek <rtayek@ca.rr.com> wrote:
On 6/15/2015 9:08 AM, James Propp wrote:
... Fear No Spam: ... go to http://mathenchant.org ... from time to ...
it may not be you, but playing the video in divx has *lots* of adds and playing the the windows player gets strange behaviour.
thanks
-- Honesty is a very expensive gift. So, don't expect it from cheap people - Warren Buffett http://tayek.com/
_______________________________________________ math-fun mailing list math-fun@mailman.xmission.com https://mailman.xmission.com/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/math-fun
_______________________________________________ math-fun mailing list math-fun@mailman.xmission.com https://mailman.xmission.com/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/math-fun
-- Mike Stay - metaweta@gmail.com http://www.cs.auckland.ac.nz/~mike http://reperiendi.wordpress.com
On 6/15/2015 11:49 AM, Mike Stay wrote:
I don't see any ads on your video. I suspect that Ray's computer may have malware. my apologies. the ads are there when i just run the player. my bad.
thanks
On Mon, Jun 15, 2015 at 11:44 AM, James Propp <jamespropp@gmail.com> wrote:
Is anyone else seeing ads when they try to view my "Magic, Magic, and Mystery" video?
Does anyone know why this would happen, and in particular, whether it has something to do with Wordpress?
The video is hosted at http://faculty.uml.edu/jpropp/MathMagicMystery.mp4, so I'm sure that the ads Ray is seeing have nothing to do with the hosting site.
Jim Propp
On Mon, Jun 15, 2015 at 2:32 PM, Ray Tayek <rtayek@ca.rr.com> wrote:
On 6/15/2015 9:08 AM, James Propp wrote:
... Fear No Spam: ... go to http://mathenchant.org ... from time to ... it may not be you, but playing the video in divx has *lots* of adds and playing the the windows player gets strange behaviour.
thanks
-- Honesty is a very expensive gift. So, don't expect it from cheap people - Warren Buffett http://tayek.com/
_______________________________________________ math-fun mailing list math-fun@mailman.xmission.com https://mailman.xmission.com/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/math-fun
_______________________________________________ math-fun mailing list math-fun@mailman.xmission.com https://mailman.xmission.com/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/math-fun
-- Honesty is a very expensive gift. So, don't expect it from cheap people - Warren Buffett http://tayek.com/
* James Propp <jamespropp@gmail.com> [Jun 16. 2015 13:09]:
Is anyone else seeing ads when they try to view my "Magic, Magic, and Mystery" video?
I see another type of problem. Chromium gives "unknown network error", so I tried wget: % wget http://faculty.uml.edu/jpropp/MathMagicMystery.mp4 --2015-06-16 16:46:24-- http://faculty.uml.edu/jpropp/MathMagicMystery.mp4 Resolving faculty.uml.edu (faculty.uml.edu)... 129.63.176.211 Connecting to faculty.uml.edu (faculty.uml.edu)|129.63.176.211|:80... connected. HTTP request sent, awaiting response... 200 OK Length: 3783801041 (3.5G) [video/mpeg] Saving to: ‘MathMagicMystery.mp4’ MathMagicMystery.mp4 0%[ ] 1024K 687KB/s in 1.5s 2015-06-16 16:46:27 (687 KB/s) - Read error at byte 1048321/3783801041 (Connection reset by peer). Retrying. --2015-06-16 16:46:28-- (try: 2) http://faculty.uml.edu/jpropp/MathMagicMystery.mp4 Connecting to faculty.uml.edu (faculty.uml.edu)|129.63.176.211|:80... connected. HTTP request sent, awaiting response... 206 Partial Content Length: 3783801041 (3.5G), 3782752720 (3.5G) remaining [video/mpeg] Saving to: ‘MathMagicMystery.mp4’ MathMagicMystery.mp4 0%[ ] 11.08M 588KB/s eta 1h 47m Here I killed the download (not being willing to wait almost 2 hours). Maybe your school throttles bandwidth (or lacks bandwidth). Note that file appears to be 3.5 GigaBytes! Best regards, jj
[...]
Because I wondered what things had been thrice attenuated, Fate and Google led me to Strange Attractors: Poems of Love and Mathematics Sarah Glaz, Joanne Growney 2008, Mathematics isbn 1439865183 And I remembered how it was to fall in love With a number, with a number theorist, With poetry. Such a spell. ... I still wonder about those thrice attentuated shades. Thing[shade] / y / y / y Why? Hilarie
Date: Mon, 15 Jun 2015 12:08:21 -0400 From: James Propp <jamespropp@gmail.com> Subject: [math-fun] Mathematical Enchantments ... I'll close with a poem by Clarence Wylie whose final line compresses into ten syllables a surprisingly large chunk of what I'll be trying to convey in these many dozens of blog posts:
PARADOX
Not truth, nor certainty. These I forswore In my novitiate, as young men called To holy orders must abjure the world. "If ..., then ...," this only I assert; And my successes are but pretty chains Linking twin doubts, for it is vain to ask If what I postulate be justified Or what I prove possess the stamp of fact. Yet bridges stand, and men no longer crawl In two dimensions. And such triumphs stem In no small measure from the power this game, Played with the thrice attenuated shades Of things, has over their originals. How frail the wand, but how profound the spell!
"Thrice attenuated shades of things" may mean that mathematics is written as lines (one dimension), but "things" are three dimensions. "Shades" is just poetic. Hilarie
"Thrice attenuated shades of things" may mean that mathematics is written as lines (one dimension), but "things" are three dimensions. "Shades" is just poetic. Hilarie
participants (5)
-
Hilarie Orman -
James Propp -
Joerg Arndt -
Mike Stay -
Ray Tayek