17 Jun
2012
17 Jun
'12
5:55 a.m.
Consider a p*p chessboard, and place an arrangement of p non- attacking rooks on it. There are clearly p! ways in which this can be done. If we interpret the chessboard instead as a torus, and let translations of the board be considered equivalent, then there are fewer unique arrangements. Out of the p² symmetries, 1 (the identity) fixes p! arrangements; 2(p-1) (vertical/horizontal translations) fix no arrangements; and the remaining (p-1)² each fix p arrangements. Hence, there are [p!+p(p-1)²]/p² = [(p-1)!+(p-1)²]/p unique arrangements, up to toroidal translations of the board, by Burnside's Lemma. This must be an integer, so (p-1)! is congruent to -1 modulo p. QED. Sincerely, Adam P. Goucher